The short answer: measure your dog’s neck where you want the bottom edge of the collar to sit. Wrap the tape snugly, with no extra room but without squeezing, and use that number as the neck size. Measure your dog, not an old collar.
Why the bottom edge?
My collars come in different widths, from 1/2" to 2". A wide collar takes up more of the neck, and necks get thicker toward the shoulders. If you measure where the middle of a wide collar will sit, the bottom edge ends up tighter than you expect and the collar rides too high. Measuring at the bottom edge gives the right fit for every width.
What you need
- A soft sewing tape measure. No tape? Use a piece of string or a phone charging cable, mark it, then lay it along a ruler.
- A treat, and maybe a helper to keep your dog still. Measuring after a walk, when your dog is relaxed, makes it easier.
Step by step
- Find the spot. Decide where you want the bottom edge of the collar to sit. Buckle collars usually sit about halfway down the neck.
- Wrap the tape flat around the neck. Snug against the fur, with no extra room, but not squeezing. Don’t add room for two fingers. I size the collar from the snug number.
- Read the number and measure a second time to be sure.
- Choose that neck size on the listing.
Fluffy dog? Measure with the fur, the way the collar will sit day to day.
Snug or loose? It’s your choice
- Like a snug collar? Measure higher on the neck. This is also the place to measure for dogs who slip out of collars: just behind the ears, where the collar can’t easily slip over the head.
- Like it to sit low and loose? Measure lower, closer to the shoulders.
- Not sure? Choose an adjustable buckle. Once you know how your dog likes to wear it, you can switch to a quick-release on your next order. An adjustable buckle is also the best choice for puppies and dogs whose coat changes with grooming.
Exact sizing and quick-release buckles
Neck sizes on the listings go in steps, but you can give me your measurement to the nearest 1/4". If you’re between sizes, just write your exact measurement in the “Anything else?” field when you order. This matters most for quick-release buckles, which don’t adjust much.
Each collar is handmade, and a collar isn’t a perfect circle, so allow about 1/2" of variation.
Martingales and half-slips
These slip on over the head, so you need one more number: the widest part of your dog’s head, usually across the ears. Choose a neck size 0.5–1" bigger than that head measurement. Any bigger and your dog may be able to back out.
For a perfect fit: the paper collar
If you want to be really sure, make a test collar out of paper:
- Cut a strip of paper the same width as the collar you’re ordering, and a little longer than the neck.
- Wrap it around your dog’s neck where you want the collar to sit and tape the ends together.
- Check it with your dog standing, sitting and lying down. Adjust until it feels right.
- Cut the loop open and measure the length of the paper. That’s your neck size.
Why not measure an old collar?
It seems easier, but an old collar’s length rarely matches the neck size you need:
- Inside vs outside: a collar wraps in a circle. The inside edge, which touches the neck, is shorter than the outside, and the thicker the material, the bigger the difference. A collar laid flat doesn’t tell you the inside measurement.
- Buckle overlap: where the tongue sits and how much strap overlaps changes the fit, and every buckle style is different.
- Width and stiffness: a narrow, soft collar sits differently from a wide or stiffer one, so the same length can fit very differently.
- Different makers, different sizing: some brands measure total length, others to a middle hole.
Measuring the neck itself is the only way to be sure.
Not sure about width or buckle size? The collar finder suggests both from your dog’s breed, weight and neck.
Popular picks
Large Simple Dog CollarAn everyday collar for necks 11–22". Adjustable buckle, or quick-release on request.From $46
Small Simple Dog CollarLight and plain for necks 8–15". Adjustable or quick-release.From $40
More guides: all guides · collar closures compared.