← All guides

Dogs That Pull

The best harness, collar and leash, plus five steps to stop leash pulling

Black and white dog in a Y-front harness and print collar walking through autumn leaves

← All guides

The short answer: a well-fitted Y-front harness, with the leash clipped to a waist belt. If you walk on a collar, go as wide as your dog’s neck allows. Gear helps, but training is what stops pulling. My five steps are below.

Start with a Y-front harness

A Y-front harness sits on the breastbone and clears the shoulders, so your dog can move naturally while the pressure from pulling spreads across the chest instead of the throat. Fit matters most. I make mine to your dog’s measurements:

  • 3/4" wide for dogs 25–70 lb
  • 1" wide for dogs 60 lb and up

In the 60–70 lb overlap, either works. Go wider for a strong puller. My harnesses are for dogs 25 lb and up, since smaller dogs are hard to size well without a fitting. There’s also a small D-ring on the front for your dog’s tags, so their ID can ride on the harness.

Walking on a collar? Go wide

If you prefer to walk your dog on a collar, choose the widest collar their size allows. A wide collar spreads pressure over more of the neck. Not sure what that is? The collar finder suggests a width from your dog’s size and neck. For strong pullers, a half-slip is my favourite: it can’t be backed out of, and there’s no chain to fail.

Narrow collars are fine for carrying tags, but steady pressure on a narrow strip of the neck can damage the throat. Don’t clip the leash to one on a dog who pulls.

Pro tip: if your dog wears a collar and harness together, a collar-to-harness safety tab links the two, so if one ever fails, your dog is still attached.

Try a waist belt

When you hold the leash, your arm gives a little every time your dog pulls, and that give can keep them leaning into it. Clip the leash at your waist instead. My 3-Way Hands-Free Leash does this. In my experience, dogs pull less when the end of the leash is a steady anchor that doesn’t move. It also frees your hands for treats, and your core takes the load instead of your shoulder.

Strong puller? BioThane webbing is far stronger than a standard leash snap, so the clip is usually the weak point. For a big dog who pulls, swap the snap for a locking carabiner that can’t open by accident.

What to skip

  • Bungee and springy leashes. The stretch reinforces pulling: your dog leans in, the leash gives, and they get a little further.
  • Narrow collars for walking. A narrow collar puts all the pressure on a small strip of the throat. Save it for tags.
  • A standard snap on a big puller. Use a locking carabiner instead.

A note on the front clip

My Y-front harness has a front O-ring on the chest, and it can be a helpful training tool. When your dog pulls, it turns them gently back toward you, which gives you a chance to reinforce walking with you instead.

But it only works alongside training. If your dog keeps pulling straight through the front clip, it pulls across their chest and shoulders and throws off how they move, which isn’t good for their shoulders. If that’s happening, clip to the O-ring at the back of the shoulders, the everyday clip for walking, and keep working on loose-leash walking.

How to stop your dog pulling on the leash

A harness can help reduce pulling, but it won’t teach your dog to walk with you. Here’s how I teach loose-leash walking as a trainer, in five steps, using positive reinforcement only.

Step 1: Rethink the walk

Walking in a straight line at your hip isn’t natural for a dog, it isn’t much fun, and it doesn’t burn off any of their energy. A tight heel has its place for short stretches: in competition, in a training session, or squeezing past people on a crowded sidewalk. But that’s not what a walk is for.

Smell is your dog’s main way of taking in the world. Dogs have up to 300 million scent receptors, compared to about 6 million in our noses, and the part of their brain that makes sense of smells is, proportionally, about 40 times bigger than ours. Where we might stop to take in a view, your dog takes in a pile of leaves. For a dog, sniffing isn’t a nice extra. It’s a need.

It’s good for them, too. In one study, dogs who spent two weeks doing sniffing and searching games became more optimistic, while dogs who practised heeling instead didn’t change. In another, dogs’ pulse rates dropped every time they stopped to sniff, by as much as 20%, and dogs on a longer leash sniffed almost three times as much. Sniffing is hard work for the brain, too. In my experience, a slow, sniffy walk tires a dog out far more than a brisk march.

The walk is for your dog to sniff. That’s the whole point. So instead of planning a 1 km walk, plan to sniff 100 things. Lead your dog from one sniffable spot to the next: bushes, posts, corners, the base of a tree. Zigzag. Wander. Over time your dog learns there’s no rush. They’re not trying to get somewhere, so they can slow down and sniff.

How to accidentally teach a dog to pull: Clip your dog on, hold them tight at your hip so they can’t sniff, explore or burn off any energy, then march them straight to somewhere really exciting, like the off-leash park. Repeat daily. Every day the pulling gets a little stronger. Walking pinned at your hip is boring and frustrating, and pulling is how they got to the fun.

Step 2: Stop moving forward when your dog pulls

This is the most important rule I teach. If your dog pulls and you keep walking the way they’re pulling, they learn that pulling works. So when the leash goes tight, do literally anything else:

  • Stop and wait for the leash to go loose, then carry on.
  • Change direction.
  • Walk in a zigzag.
  • Toss a treat behind you, and move on once they’ve found it.

The exception is extreme distraction. If there’s a squirrel, or your dog is beside themselves to see someone, that’s not the moment to practise leash walking, unless your dog is already very advanced. Get through it as calmly as you can (the front clip helps here) and practise somewhere easier.

Step 3: The kibble dispenser

This is the heart of loose-leash walking, and you’re the dispenser. Fill a treat pouch with your dog’s regular kibble. As you walk, hand-deliver one piece at a time just behind your hip.

  1. Start by feeding constantly, almost every step.
  2. Then count your steps: feed every 2 steps, then every 3.
  3. Keep stretching it out: every 10 steps, then 20.

Over time, your dog builds a default position for walking: close to you, with a loose leash, because that’s where the good stuff happens.

For high-energy dogs: if your dog is wound up and hasn’t burned off any energy yet, toss the kibble into the grass or bushes instead, one piece at a time, and let them sniff it out. Sniffing settles them, and they still learn that good things happen near you.

Step 4: Add sniffing stations

Once the kibble dispenser is going well, build stations along your route that your dog loves. It depends on your dog, but two of my favourites:

  • The sausage tree (also called a cheese tree). Find a tree with rough bark, a stump or a brick wall, and tuck tiny bits of food into the nooks and crannies, at different heights. Then let your dog sniff them all out.
  • A scatter. Toss a handful of kibble into a grassy patch and let them hunt for every piece.

Step 5: Mix in other training

Breaking up the walk with training that has nothing to do with leash walking keeps your dog interested in you, and reminds them they’re not on the way somewhere. Try tricks like spins, hopping up onto a bench or log, or paws up on a tree or wall. They keep your dog’s attention and their body close to you.

What I don’t use

No leash pops, prong, choke or shock collars. The Canadian Veterinary Medical Association, the BC SPCA’s AnimalKind standards and the American Veterinary Society of Animal Behavior all recommend reinforcement-based training. So do I, and I’m AnimalKind accredited. Corrections can make walks stressful and damage the trust between you and your dog, and they don’t teach your dog what to do instead.

Give your puller a job

Some dogs just love to pull, and that’s not a bad thing. Hiking is a great outlet. Uphill, a little help from a strong dog is welcome, and pulling is great exercise for them.

The trick is to put pulling on cue, so your dog learns when it’s allowed. I use “hike”, but any word works. The word isn’t the only cue, either. The hill and the clip become part of it too.

  1. Clip to the back D-ring. On my harness, it’s the ring made for pulling sports and hiking. Use it only for pulling, every time.
  2. Use the hill. As the trail climbs, say your cue word and let them lean in. Reinforce pulling with praise, and now and then toss a treat up the trail ahead of them. For a dog who loves to pull, the pulling itself is reinforcing too.
  3. Be consistent. When you always use the same clip on the same kind of terrain, your dog learns the context: back clip, uphill and “hike” means pulling is welcome.

It works the other way too. Going downhill, switch to the front clip. The front clip and the slope become your dog’s cue to slow down and stay behind you. Reinforce easing off and walking at your pace.

Over time, your dog learns that pulling has a time and a place, and you get a happy, tired dog and a helping hand on the climbs.

My picks

More guides: all guides · reactive dogs · collar rules for dog sports · collar finder.